Comments on: The People Want The Census http://www.calgaryliberal.com/2010/07/25/the-people-want-the-census/ A political blog for a political city. Sun, 15 Jan 2012 00:35:33 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.1 By: LibVin http://www.calgaryliberal.com/2010/07/25/the-people-want-the-census/#comment-1695 LibVin Mon, 26 Jul 2010 01:43:47 +0000 http://www.calgaryliberal.com/?p=1388#comment-1695 Fred, the decision is unpopular <b>and</b> bad. Tomm, you are misrepresenting the census. It isn't the specific details on an individual person that statisticians care about. Or if you--and I mean <b>you</b>--have thirty or zero bathrooms. Ottawa and the bureaucrats there care about the trends and the general movements of things in Canada. To put the argument into the single, individual sense is making a severe misrepresentation of what the census actually does. Next, it's anonymous. If you don't want to give your name the census takers accepts pseudonyms and, well, any name you damn well please. A single individual's identification is unimportant to the census. Again, let me repeat this, it's anonymous and people are protected. These general trends in addition to anonymity, in addition to the maddening level of privacy protections by StatsCan, makes both your point and Harper's actions irrevocably idiotic. So your perceived 'threat' of big-bad-Ottawa is misplaced in addition to being a misrepresentation of the facts of the matter. And I call bull shit on the call of being "just all Canadians." We are all individuals, with our own minds, and our own needs/desires. To downgrade that complexity in favor of nationalistic platitudes to both foolhardy and self-destructive. So toss the rhetoric and stick to the facts, Tomm. Fred, the decision is unpopular and bad.
Tomm, you are misrepresenting the census. It isn’t the specific details on an individual person that statisticians care about. Or if you–and I mean you–have thirty or zero bathrooms. Ottawa and the bureaucrats there care about the trends and the general movements of things in Canada. To put the argument into the single, individual sense is making a severe misrepresentation of what the census actually does.
Next, it’s anonymous. If you don’t want to give your name the census takers accepts pseudonyms and, well, any name you damn well please. A single individual’s identification is unimportant to the census. Again, let me repeat this, it’s anonymous and people are protected.
These general trends in addition to anonymity, in addition to the maddening level of privacy protections by StatsCan, makes both your point and Harper’s actions irrevocably idiotic.
So your perceived ‘threat’ of big-bad-Ottawa is misplaced in addition to being a misrepresentation of the facts of the matter.
And I call bull shit on the call of being “just all Canadians.” We are all individuals, with our own minds, and our own needs/desires. To downgrade that complexity in favor of nationalistic platitudes to both foolhardy and self-destructive. So toss the rhetoric and stick to the facts, Tomm.

]]> By: Fred from BC http://www.calgaryliberal.com/2010/07/25/the-people-want-the-census/#comment-1694 Fred from BC Mon, 26 Jul 2010 01:29:06 +0000 http://www.calgaryliberal.com/?p=1388#comment-1694 Tomm on July 25th, 2010 at 8:29 AM # <i>The people also want free ice cream, freedom from work. </i> Absolutely. Good thing the country isn't governed by polls, or we might be in the same financial situation as California. Part of being a leader is making decisions...some of which will no doubt be unpopular. Tomm on July 25th, 2010 at 8:29 AM #

The people also want free ice cream, freedom from work.

Absolutely. Good thing the country isn’t governed by polls, or we might be in the same financial situation as California. Part of being a leader is making decisions…some of which will no doubt be unpopular.

]]> By: Tomm http://www.calgaryliberal.com/2010/07/25/the-people-want-the-census/#comment-1692 Tomm Sun, 25 Jul 2010 14:29:57 +0000 http://www.calgaryliberal.com/?p=1388#comment-1692 The people also want free ice cream, freedom from work. The census is instrusive. If you get the long form, fill it out. But why is it a statistician's choice in Ottawa whether you HAVE to fill it out? What business is it of the state to know your sexual orientation? who does the work in your house? or what "ethnic group" you came from? Wouldn't it be nice if we were all just Canadian's? One other thing... Just because you do a poll doesn't mean "the people". The people also want free ice cream, freedom from work.

The census is instrusive. If you get the long form, fill it out. But why is it a statistician’s choice in Ottawa whether you HAVE to fill it out?

What business is it of the state to know your sexual orientation? who does the work in your house? or what “ethnic group” you came from? Wouldn’t it be nice if we were all just Canadian’s?

One other thing… Just because you do a poll doesn’t mean “the people”.

]]>